Francis POULENC: Opéra en trois actes et douze tableaux
Livret d'Emmet Lavery, d'après un drame de Georges Bernanos
Lui-même inspiré d'un roman de Gertrude von Le Fort
et d'un scénario de R. P Bruckberger et de Ph. Agostini
Créé en Italien à la Scala de Milan, le 26 Janvier 1957
Among the piles of music DVDs in Quiapo, sandwiched between Sarah Geronimo and Dixie Chicks was an opera about 18th century Carmelite nuns: Francis Poulenc’s operatic masterpiece Dialogues des Carmelites.
Context: During the French Revolution of the late 1700s, when the Bastille was taken over and controlled by the revolutionaries, members of the aristocracy, the political elite and the Church were persecuted because they were all considered part of the old order which oppressed and exploited the peasants and the masses. As such, all religious orders were disbanded and declared illegal by the tribunal, nuns and priests were ordered out of their cloisters. It was under this political turmoil in France that Poulenc set his opera.
The story takes place during the waning days of the French revolution and revolves around Blanche de la Force, a high-strung girl from a rich family who can't cope with the world, and so decides to become a Carmelite nun.
The first act sees Blanche persuading her father, the Marquis and her brother the Chevalier to join a Carmelite monastery. Living under troubled times and plagued with paranoia since her mother’s accidental death, Blanche appears tortured and unsettled by existential fears. She wants to seek shelter in the walls of the cloister. But in the following interview with the Prioress Madame de Croissy, Blanche has to persuade the Prioress who is suspicious of her motives, but she eventually got admitted.
A brief dialogue between Blanche and the other cheerful young novice sister, Constance with whom she shares work ensue. Constance reveals she is willing to sacrifice her life if it would save the dying Prioress. But Blanche's fear of death makes her shrink from such a thought.
And then the highly anticipated mad scene: Prioress Madame de Croissy dies in one of the greatest dramatic moments in modern opera. The terror and the last minute crisis of faith become apparent as the Prioress become delirious. Witnessed by Blanche and Mother Marie, one of the senior nuns, she predicts a desecration of their convent and serious trouble in the near future, before breathing her last.
In the following scene, Blanche is unable to contain her acute fear of death during the death watch, so much that she deserts her duty and incurs the ire of Mother Marie.
A new Prioress is selected, Madame Lidoine, instead of Mother Marie.
Blanche's brother the Chevalier (Laurence Dale, who looks every inch like an 18th century French nobleman who's worried sick about his sister) visits her and pleads for her in vain to return to her father where she would be safe from the revolutionaries. Not long after, the revolutionary commissioners dissolve the cloister and throw the nuns out into the streets.
In the final Act, the sisters, stripped of their habits, take an oath of martyrdom. Blanche seeks refuge in her father's house only to find he has been guillotined. The Act culminates in one of the most chilling finales in all opera: the mass execution of the nuns. As Constance, the last nun to be beheaded, walks to the scaffold, Blanche finds the courage to face her fear of death and walks out of the crowd to join her.
This 1999 production at the Opéra National du Rhin in Strasbourg, France succeeded in evoking the feeling of restlessness and unease during the French revolution, especially the atmosphere of fear that seems to permeate the air. Taking a minimalist approach, the production manages to convey the austere atmosphere of a convent.
Poulenc’s music lies between Debussy’s Pelleas et Melisande in its depictions of an almost mythical far-removed setting of the world of the cloistered nuns -- and Wagner’s leitmotif style and brilliant strokes of orchestration that seem to comment on every psychological detail.
The Latin prayers were astoundingly surreal and out-of-this-world: Ave Maria, Ave Verum Corpus and the chilling and unforgettable final prayer, Salve Regina as the nuns walk to the scaffold to be executed.
But what astonishes me is the first-rate acting. Mezzo soprano Anne Sophie Schmidt brilliantly portrays Poulenc’s unlikely heroine, Blanche de la Force. She completely owned the part, convincing in showing Blanche’s tortured but innocent soul. She communicated the character’s vulnerability as well as the nagging torment very well. Blanche joined the convent mainly to look for solace and shelter from the outside world, only to find out that the walls of the cloister cannot shield her from all her fears, especially of death.
Patricia Petibon delivered a tour de force performance as Constance. She radiates a serene spiritual beauty and her singing is purely angelic, the complete anti-thesis to Blanche’s personality.
Nadine Denize as the Prioress mesmerizes in her crisis of faith, communicating her hysteria and terror with great emotional force. I believe the immense dramatic possibilities attracted the great Joan Sutherland to undertake this role in an earlier well-acclaimed production, although the role was written for a contralto.
Hedwig Fassbender as Mother Marie shows intense emotional control, a no mean feat. Her character demands firmness, level-headedness and strength during the turbulent times and she beautifully communicates warmth and compassion at the same time. She held her ground in her exchanges with the leader of the mob who came to drive them out of the cloister. That scene is precious. In addition, the tension between her and the new Prioress is so subdued, nothing much is said, but you can feel it burning in the air.
Simplicity and austerity are important elements in the whole production. Take the execution scene. No scaffold, no block; the nuns stand in line across the stage to come forward either singly or in pairs to fall to the ground at the sound of a falling guillotine.
The music makes it all eerie: it is clearly a slow, death march, as the drums and bells make it all too obvious. The nuns sing the final unforgettable prayer in an all-out chorus in full fortissimo, the Salve Regina, a last appeal for deliverance, with defiance and quiet fortitude. The music is repeatedly interrupted by the sound of a falling guillotine -- zing!-- as the nuns take their turns to be executed at the scaffold, decimating the chorus one-by-one, to the very last voice.
Watching this is a rewarding, unforgettable experience. Highly recommended.